Artist: Elvis Costello Album: Brutal Youth

Year: 1994
Duration: 0:0-1

A Brutal Review of Elvis Costello's Brutal Youth

Elvis Costello is a legend in the punk and new wave scene, and his album Brutal Youth is considered a classic by many. Released in 1994, it came after a few tepid albums that left fans and critics wondering if Costello's creative spark had dimmed. But Brutal Youth proved that he still had plenty of fire in him. In this blog post, we'll take a critical look at the album, analyze its strengths and weaknesses, and offer our thoughts on its place in Costello's discography.

Brutal Youth was a return to form for Costello. He had reunited with his backing band, the Attractions, who hadn't played together in a decade. The album showcases Costello's signature sound - punchy guitars, driving rhythms, and clever lyrics that often take aim at societal issues. The opening track, Pony St., is a perfect example of this. It attacks the corporate world, with its chorus of Pony, pony representing the monotonous routine of a 9-5 job.

But while Brutal Youth has plenty of standout tracks, it's not perfect. The album's production is a bit muddy, with the bass and drums often getting lost in the mix. Additionally, some of the tracks feel undercooked, such as Clown Strike and Favourite Hour. They lack the energy and urgency of other songs on the album and can feel like filler.

That being said, there are some real gems on Brutal Youth. 13 Steps Led Down is one of Costello's best songs, with its biting lyrics and catchy melody. Kinder Murder is another highlight, featuring a killer bassline and chorus that's impossible not to sing along to. And Sulky Girl is a moody ballad that showcases Costello's vulnerable side.

One of the most innovative parts of Brutal Youth is the way it blends different genres. While punk and new wave are the foundation, there are also elements of country, jazz, and even orchestral music. The strings on Rocking Horse Road add a cinematic quality to the track, while the twangy guitar on 13 Steps Led Down gives it a Western feel. It's this willingness to experiment that makes Brutal Youth stand out from other punk albums of the time.

Critically speaking, Brutal Youth received positive reviews upon its release. It was praised for its energy and songwriting, with many considering it a return to form for Costello. However, some critics felt that it lacked cohesion and suffered from the aforementioned production issues. It's certainly not without its flaws, but it remains a beloved album among Costello fans and is a must-listen for anyone interested in punk or new wave.

Brutal Youth is a compelling examination of society's flaws and a testament to Costello's songwriting ability. While it's not perfect, it's an album that rewards repeated listens and showcases the best of what punk and new wave had to offer in the mid-90s. Costello's willingness to experiment and blend different genres makes it an album that has stood the test of time, and one that any fan of his or of punk rock in general should check out.