The Enduring Appeal of Savatage's Music: A Look at The Good and The Bad

Savatage has been one of the most beloved metal bands since their start in 1979, and over the past thirty-plus years the legendary band has created hits that are still remembered by fans. Savatage's music is often credited with pushing metal to more complex levels but it can be easy to overlook some of its shortcomings when getting caught up in nostalgia for classic songs like 'Gutter Ballet' or 'Hall of The Mountain King.' While there have certainly been a few clunkers along the way as well, I'm here to look at both sides and offer an objective analysis on why Savatage continues to draw in listeners even today - warts and all.

Savatage. A name that conjures up memories of headbanging in the 80s and rifftastic melodies that have stood the test of time. In the world of metal, they are often considered as pioneers who pushed the boundaries of the genre. But like any band that has been around for over three decades, they've had their share of highs and lows. In this blog, I'm going to take a deep dive into what makes the music of Savatage so enduring for metal fans - the good and the bad.

Let's start with the good. Savatage's music was always known for its complexity and the sheer genius of Jon Oliva's songwriting. The fusion of power metal, progressive rock, and classical music elements was a signature style that set them apart from other metal acts of their era. Take, for example, the song Edge of Thorns. It's one of their most epic tracks and showcases their ability to incorporate complex time signatures, soaring guitar solos, and catchy choruses that stick in your head. It's no surprise that this song has remained a fan favorite over the years and is often cited as the band's crowning achievement.

Another aspect of Savatage's music that drew fans in was the emotional depth of their lyrics. From their early days as a straightforward metal act to their later, more conceptual albums, the band was never afraid to tackle difficult themes. Take, for instance, the track Chance from the album Dead Winter Dead. The song talks about the futility of war and how the human cost is often overlooked. It's a powerful message that resonates with listeners to this day, especially in times of conflict.

Now, on to the not-so-good. For all their musical prowess, there have been some missteps along the way. One criticism that some listeners have leveled against their music is that it can be too over-the-top and bombastic. They pushed the boundaries of metal too far at times, leading to songs that are overly complex and lack the punch of their earlier material. For example, the album Streets: A Rock Opera featured a story that was so convoluted that it overshadowed the music. The band took a risk by trying to create something new and different, but in the end, it didn't quite work.

Another criticism that has been leveled against Savatage's music is that sometimes it can be cheesy. Some of their concept albums, especially the ones that deal with medieval themes, can come across as a bit campy. While this might be a turn-off for some listeners, it's also part of what makes the band unique. They were never afraid to take risks and try something new, even if it meant that their music would be less accessible.

At the end of the day, the music of Savatage continues to inspire and connect with fans despite its flaws. They might not have always hit the mark with every album, but their influence on the metal genre cannot be ignored. Their fusion of classical music elements with heavy metal showed that metal could be more than just mindless thrashing. They tackled difficult themes with their lyrics and created emotional depth that fans still find powerful. In short, Savatage's music might not be perfect, but it's undeniably compelling. It's what keeps fans coming back year after year, and why they remain one of the most beloved bands in the world of metal.